Northern Ag Network
Northern Ag Network
Northern Broadcasting System    Northern News Network    Northern Sports Network
Search This Site...
Search This Site...

Farm Bill: Government 1, Free Market 0.

Guest Opinion by Tom Dennis of the Grand Forks Herald.

2/10/2014 6:21:00 PM/Categories: Opinions, Farm Bill, Farm Bill

Democrats don’t yet seem to realize it. But the fact is, their party won a big policy debate in recent weeks — and because that debate for years has been a factor in government shutdowns and other Washington crises, the Dems’ victory is worth noting.

The debate has centered on this question: Can government subsidies and other interventions ever help the U.S. economy and leave Americans better off? The victory arises because Congress now has answered that question by saying “yes.” And not just any “yes,” but a “yes” that drew support from a majority of Republicans (162-63) in the House and almost half — 22 for, 23 against — of GOPers in the Senate.Those votes, of course, came as both houses approved the Farm Bill and sent the bill to the president. You can’t overestimate the Farm Bill vote’s importance in America’s debate on the role of government. For the Farm Bill represents a deliberate and multi-billion dollar rejection of the claim that a free-market approach always is best. Congress in general and Republicans in particular had a choice. Indeed, Congress in general and Republicans in particular have had a choice every few years since the Depression. That choice has been whether to keep offering a national program of farm supports or to withdraw those supports and let farmers succeed or fail on their own.The 2014 choice now has been made. The rubber has met the road. And members of Congress, Democrats and Republicans alike, unambiguously made their preferences known: The Farm Bill passed with bipartisan supermajorities in both houses.Government intervention won, and the free-market lost. Why? In our view, the Farm Bill passed for exactly the reason why it should have passed: Because the Farm Bill works. Since the first Farm Bill in the 1930s, rural America has been transformed, becoming much healthier and more prosperous than it had been in the decades before that.

The interstate highway system helped. The fact that rural states each have two senators helped as well. But the various Farm Bills also have played a role. 

And urban as well as rural residents agree. No such high-profile policy could have survived for 80 years on interest-group politics alone. Obviously, urban Americans have decided they’re better off with a prosperous “hinterland,” with its bounty of produce, vast landscape of successful farms and network of friendly towns and dynamic cities. As mentioned before in this space, farm-state Republicans deserve great credit for recognizing that in this instance, intervention works, at least in the eyes of most Americans and their representatives.  

Now, here’s an interesting set of questions for those Republicans to ponder:  Might there be other areas in which government action can be a net plus? Or, by remarkable coincidence, is farming both the only industry where the libertarian philosophy falls short and a key element in rural politicians’ self-interest?  In recent years, many liberals have acknowledged that when it comes to the connection between poverty and single-parent homes, conservatives have something useful to say. And if the Farm Bill vote is any indication, it’s conservatives turn to nod in the liberals’ direction — this time on the idea that the government isn’t always the problem after all. 

Leave a comment

Add comment


Recent Ag News

American Crystal, Big Sky Sugar Discuss Future of Sidney, MT Processing Facility

11/20/2018 11:20:00 AM
Representatives of American Crystal Sugar Company and Big Sky Sugar Cooperative announced today that they have signed a non-binding letter of intent providing the framework by which Big Sky would become the owner of the Sidney, MT sugar processing facility.  >> Read More
Article rating: No rating

New Brucellosis Infection Reported in Wyoming's Sublette County

11/20/2018 8:19:00 AM
Wyoming state veterinarian, Dr. Jim Logan, has been notified by the Wyoming State Veterinary Laboratory and the National Veterinary Services Laboratory there is another new case of brucellosis in a cattle herd in Wyoming - this time in Sublette County which is in the Wyoming Brucellosis Designated Surveillance Area (DSA).  >> Read More
Article rating: No rating

Army Greens Uniform Heavy on American Wool

11/20/2018 5:26:00 AM
The United States Army announced on Veteran's Day that it is adopting an iconic uniform - the Army Greens - as its new service uniform. This is the uniform worn by America's Greatest Generation in World War II.  >> Read More
Article rating: No rating

Get Your BQA Certification Now—Some Packers To Require It in 2019

11/20/2018 5:17:00 AM
Earlier this year, several beef packers announced they would require Beef Quality Assurance (BQA) certification from fed cattle suppliers, starting Jan. 1, 2019. Leaders from Tyson and Cargill say this effort is driven by beef retailers and consumers, who are asking for more information about how cattle are raised. >> Read More
Article rating: No rating

Cattlemen Want Alternative Proteins Properly Regulated

11/19/2018 1:06:00 PM
Montana ranchers produce some of highest quality beef you’ll find anywhere. But here of late, plant-based proteins and lab grown meat have grabbed the headlines and cattlemen and cattlewomen want to protect the integrity of their industry thru proper labeling of these alternative proteins. >> Read More
Article rating: No rating

Find Articles by Date

«November 2018»