Move to Restrict President’s Power to Create National Monuments Defeated


by Suzanne Potter, Public News Service – NV


CARSON CITY, Nev. – A move to gut the Antiquities Act and effectively block a U.S. president from declaring new national monuments died in the U.S. Senate on Tuesday.

The president now has the power to create a national monument by executive order. The Senate defeated an amendment to the energy bill that would have made all new national-monument designations temporary, for three years, and subject to approval by Congress and the appropriate state legislature.

David Von Seggern, who chairs the executive committee of the Sierra Club's Toiyabe Chapter, said he's glad the Senate rejected the move.

“It's important that a president have this power because, when he does this, he's speaking for all the American people that own these lands,” he said. “These lands are already federal lands, and they're receiving an extra level of protection.”

President Obama created two national monuments in Nevada last year: Tule Springs Fossil Beds and Basin and Range national monuments. Von Seggern said the latter was opposed by several of Nevada's elected representatives in Washington who support more energy development on federal lands.

“The Basin and Range National Monument was controversial, and our state federal legislators were not bringing it forward for national monument status,” he said, “so, the president used his power from the Antiquities Act to designate that.”

The Antiquities Act was created in 1906 under President Theodore Roosevelt and has been used equally by Democratic and Republican presidents. Grand Canyon and Grand Teton national parks both started as national monuments created under the Antiquities Act.

The amendment text is online at

Source:  Public News Service – NV


CLICK HERE for an opposing view looking at why the Antiquities Act needs to be revised and why Congress should repeal the President’s authority to designate national monuments.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x