Op-Ed: When a Good Harvest Still Isn’t Enough

Op-Ed: When a Good Harvest Still Isn’t Enough

by Colter Brown

By Kera Birkeland – Senior Policy Advisor, Montana Grain Growers Association

A Follow-Up to “Farmers Need More Than Another Government Check“

What does it say about American agriculture when a farmer can have a good harvest, receive crop insurance and government assistance, and still struggle to break even?

What does it say when a farmer who has spent years dreaming of expanding his operation is finally offered more land, but instead of excitement, feels hesitation?

These are real conversations taking place among Montana grain producers.

In our earlier article, “A Bridge, Not a Road,” we made the case that emergency farm assistance is sometimes necessary, but it cannot become the foundation of American agriculture. A bridge is meant to help us cross a difficult stretch. It is not supposed to become the road itself. Today, farmers are telling us something even more concerning: We are still on that bridge, and the road ahead is becoming harder to see.

When Success Doesn’t Pay

For many Montana grain producers, this year’s harvest brought welcome yields. Under normal circumstances, that should be cause for optimism. But a good harvest doesn’t necessarily mean a profitable year.

One Montana farmer recently described sitting down to pay bills after a successful growing season. Fuel, hail insurance, equipment repairs, seed, fertilizer and chemicals. Despite producing a good crop, the numbers told a discouraging story.

He had also been offered the opportunity to take over a neighboring farm as its owner retired. It was exactly the kind of opportunity he had worked toward for years. Yet instead of excitement, he questioned whether more acres, more debt and more responsibility would accomplish anything beyond increasing his financial risk.

When farmers no longer see opportunity in expansion, even after a good harvest, something is fundamentally wrong. And the numbers help explain why.

Montana producers are reporting starter fertilizer prices exceeding $1,000 per ton, urea at $640 per ton and dyed diesel approaching $5.75 per gallon. These are individual producer-reported prices, but they reflect the financial pressures facing farms across the region. Add expensive equipment, rising repair costs, transportation expenses and unpredictable markets, and even the most efficient producers are struggling to make the numbers work.

One farmer described today’s uncertainty as two or three times what he would normally expect. Even after receiving crop insurance proceeds and farm program payments, he anticipated finishing the year near break-even.

A good harvest. Insurance protection. Government assistance. And still, little to show for the investment and risk.

Farmers Want Markets, Not Dependence

The Trump administration’s recently announced $8 billion Harvest Fuel Relief Program recognizes the serious financial pressures facing American agriculture. We appreciate that recognition and the willingness to provide relief.

But farmers are increasingly uncomfortable with how dependent their businesses have become on government support.

They are tired of being labeled welfare recipients when they would much rather earn their income from the marketplace. They are tired of explaining why assistance is necessary when accepting it may be the difference between planting another crop and walking away.

And they are asking an important question: When billions of dollars in assistance enter the agricultural economy, how much ultimately remains with the farmer?

Producers worry that assistance intended to stabilize their operations may eventually be absorbed by higher input prices, equipment costs, land rents and other expenses. When farmers have limited choices among fertilizer suppliers, equipment manufacturers, transportation providers and grain buyers, they have little leverage over the prices they pay and receive.

Competition is farm policy. Government assistance may help pay the bills, but it cannot replace competitive markets or long-term profitability.

The Cost We Aren’t Measuring

There is another cost to this agricultural economy that doesn’t appear on a balance sheet.

One producer put it simply: He was tired. Tired of trying to time every purchase perfectly. Tired of marketing grain at exactly the right moment. Tired of escalating costs, paperwork and uncertainty.

Farmers understand hard work and risk. But there is a difference between accepting the inherent challenges of agriculture and operating in an environment where even success may not be enough. That exhaustion affects whether young people enter agriculture, whether established producers expand and whether families believe there is a future worth passing on to the next generation.

We talk a great deal about the financial sustainability of agriculture. We should be equally concerned about the sustainability of the people doing the farming.

If You Ate Today, Thank a Farmer

There are few professions that every American depends on every single day. Farming is one of them.

Whether you live in a rural community or a major city, work in an office, a hospital or a school, one thing is certain: You need food. If you ate today, somewhere along the way, a farmer made that possible.

Yet we have become so accustomed to stocked grocery shelves and an abundant food supply that it’s easy to overlook the enormous investment and risk required to make it possible.

Farmers aren’t asking to be celebrated. They are asking for the opportunity to earn a reasonable living producing something every American needs. Food security is national security. And a country that cannot sustain the people who grow its food puts its own future at risk.

Farm profitability isn’t just a farmer’s problem. It’s everyone’s problem.

It’s Time to Fix the Road

American farmers help feed our nation, but they also depend on customers beyond our borders. Strong domestic markets and reliable access to global trade are essential to keeping farms profitable and America’s food supply secure. We cannot expect farmers to remain economically viable without giving them the opportunity to compete in both.

A strong farm safety net remains essential. Crop insurance, commodity programs and emergency assistance help producers manage risks they cannot always control. We recognize the efforts of the Trump administration and Congress to provide relief, strengthen domestic fertilizer production and address the economic challenges facing agriculture.

But the ultimate measure of success cannot be how much assistance reaches farmers. It must be whether farmers are becoming less dependent on that assistance. That means addressing input affordability, market competition, transportation costs, export opportunities and policies that provide greater certainty.

The farmers sharing these experiences aren’t describing failed operations. They are describing successful harvests, working farms and producers who have spent their lives building businesses. Yet some are questioning whether the rewards still justify the investment.

That should be a wake-up call for Washington and for every American who depends on the food they produce. We cannot continue to expect farmers to shoulder extraordinary financial risk, produce an abundant food supply and then question why they need assistance when the economics no longer work.

Farmers don’t want to depend on government payments. They want to depend on the value of what they produce.

In “A Bridge, Not a Road,” we asked why farmers keep needing assistance.

The conversations we are hearing today make that question even more urgent.

If a good harvest, a strong safety net and billions in emergency assistance still aren’t enough to restore confidence in the future of farming, then it is time to stop measuring success by the size of the bridge and start asking why we haven’t fixed the road.

###

Join us December 1–2 in Great Falls for the Montana Grain Growers Association Annual Convention. It’s a chance to meet the growers behind MGGA, learn how we advocate for Montana grain producers, and talk farm policy with me, Kera Birkeland, MGGA’s senior policy advisor. I’d like to hear what’s putting the most pressure on your operation and what changes would make a difference.

In the next article, I’ll lay out a plan to fix the road, with concrete policy changes to lower the cost of producing and shipping grain, strengthen competition, and expand markets so a good harvest can translate into a profitable year.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x